02 · VaR & CFaR

Two questions, two models

VaR tells you what your positions could lose in days. CFaR tells you how far your cash flows could miss budget this year. Most treasuries need both, and few should use one in place of the other.

Earnings at Risk (millions)
0%100%
Current
hedge
Optimal
hedge
Cash Flow at Risk (millions)
Current hedge Random hedge scenarios Efficient frontier Optimal hedge

Side by side

Separate measures for separate decisions

We build each one for the question it answers, then tie them together so the board sees one picture of risk.

VaRValue at Risk

“How much could the value of our positions fall over the next few days?”

For banks, trading desks, investment portfolios, treasury dealing books

VaR 99%1 period in 100is worseExpectedshortfall0LossGainChange in portfolio value over 10 days

Illustrative distribution of 10-day value changes. VaR marks the line; expected shortfall averages the tail beyond it.

  • Parametric, historical and Monte Carlo VaR
  • Expected shortfall for what happens beyond the line
  • Daily P&L attribution and backtesting
  • FRTB-aligned methodology for regulated entities
CFaRCash Flow at Risk

“How far could our operating cash flow miss budget this year?”

For corporate treasurers, cfos, boards and lenders

BudgetCFaR5th percentileQ1Q2Q3Q4Today

Illustrative cash flow fan against budget. CFaR is the shortfall at the chosen confidence level.

  • Monte Carlo across FX, rates and commodities together
  • Correlations and forecast uncertainty modelled, not assumed
  • Hedge ratios set from the CFaR the board will tolerate
  • Covenant and rating headroom under stress
VaRCFaR
MeasuresChange in market value of positionsShortfall in cash flows against budget
Horizon1 to 10 daysQuarters to years
Driven byMarket moves on what you hold todayMarket moves on what you will receive and pay
InformsLimits, capital and trading decisionsHedge ratios, budgets, covenants and dividends

Where we apply it

Risk by risk

FX

Transactional and translation exposure, forecast confidence by horizon, and the hedge ratio that matches.

Interest rates

Fixed/floating mix, refinancing risk and EaR on the debt book; IRRBB (EVE and NII) for banks.

Commodities

Energy, metals and agricultural inputs, including basis risk between the hedge and the physical price.

Credit & counterparty

Exposure profiles, collateral and CVA, and concentration across bank counterparties.

Lease residual values

The market value of leased assets at term end: a CFaR problem hiding in the balance sheet.

Read the case study ↓

Hedge optimisation

The efficient frontier between CFaR and earnings volatility, so cost and risk are traded off explicitly.

Case study · Illustrative

Residual value risk in a lease book

A lessor prices every lease on an assumed residual value: what the asset will be worth when it comes back. Across thousands of vehicles or machines, that assumption is one of the largest risks on the balance sheet, and it is rarely measured like one.

0%25%50%75%100%Used-asset price shockRV in pricingRV at risk5th pctStartM12M24M36M48M60Lease term (months) · market value as % of original cost
Illustrative: market value of a leased asset as a share of cost over a 60-month term, with the 50% and 90% ranges and a used-asset price shock from month 30.

The situation

An equipment and vehicle lessor sets residual values at inception. Used-asset prices move with the cycle, technology and regulation, so the realised value at term end can land well below the price that was assumed.

The approach

  • Simulate used-asset prices by asset class, age and mileage
  • Aggregate across the book by maturity to get RV at risk
  • Stress test cycle downturns and technology shifts
  • Compare guarantees, remarketing agreements and RV insurance

What it changes

  • Residual values set with a known confidence, not a point guess
  • Pricing that carries the cost of the risk taken
  • Earlier warning on the maturities most exposed

Accounting angle. Under IFRS 16, lessors review estimated unguaranteed residual values regularly. For finance leases, a reduction is recognised immediately in profit or loss, so a residual value model is also a reporting control.

Start a conversation

Ready to put your treasury to work?

Book a 30-minute diagnostic call. We'll tell you within the hour whether we can help, and where the biggest wins likely sit.

Or email us directly at [email protected]